All databases follow a common workflow to search and export bibliographic collections, mainly based on three steps: 1. Write and submit a query, 2. Refine search results and 3. Export search results.
A query is usually based on a set of terms linked by boolean operators. The search engine will query the db to identify records matching the query.
i.e. TI = (bibliometric AND analysis), the search engine will search for all the records in which the title will contain the words ‘bibliometric’ and ‘analysis’ simultaneously.
Search results can be refined by applying some filtering criteria for additional fields.
i.e. selecting Document Type = ‘Journal Article’ AND Language = ‘English’ AND Timespan = 1990:2020 AND Subject Category = ‘Management’
In this step, the user must choose which metadata he wants to download and the export file format to save the results.
To be able to work, *bibliometrix* requires a minimum set of mandatory metadata (i.e. Authors' name, Title, Journal title, Affiliation, Publication year, etc.). Our advice is to always select all the metadata fields to be sure you can perform all the analyses implemented in bibliometrix.
Many databases support a variety of different export formats, some commercial (i.e. EndNote, Mendeley, etc.) and some standard (i.e. html, plaintext, BibTeX, etc.). The choice of a suitable export file will have to consider Table 1.
Bibliometrix can import bibliographic database files and references manager files, or can download data through APIs.
Bibliometrix supports bibliographic database files from Web of Science, Scopus, Dimensions, PubMed and Cochrane Library.
In Table 1, we report the complete list of export file formats supported by bibliometrix for each database.
|Web of Science||https://www.webofknowledge.com/||
Furthermore, bibliometrix provides support for the APIs (application programming interfaces) of Dimensions, NCBI PubMed and Scopus, using functions from packages dimensionsR (https://github.com/massimoaria/dimensionsR), pubmedR (https://github.com/massimoaria/pubmedR) and rscopus (https://github.com/muschellij2/rscopus), respectively (see Table 2).
|Source||API Key request||API Access||Format|
|Dimensions||Free for scientometric projects https://www.dimensions.ai/scientometric-research/||By an account and password
|Any key (3 requests/s)
By a key (10 requests/s)
|Scopus||Commercial or Institutional subscription
|By a key (10 requests/s)||xml|
A bibliographic database a very rich set of information about a scientific document that we call ‘document metadata’ or ‘bibliographic metadata’.
It is possible to distinguish among five different types of metadata:
Web of Science and Scopus allow the user to export the complete set of metadata. This means that it will be possible to perform all analyses implemented in bibliometrix. Some other databases, such as Dimensions, PubMed and Cochrane Library, export just a limited set of metadata types which implies some limitations in the choice of the analyses to carry out.
In Table 3, we show what kind of analyzes can be performed taking into account the metadata set that each database can export.
|Web of Science||
As already stated, bibliometrix works with several data formats coming from different sources.
Here, we briefly show how to import and convert data from each bibliographic database.
An export file can be read and converted using the function convert2df:
**convert2df**(*file*, *dbsource*, *format*)
The argument file is a character vector containing the export file names. file can also contain the name of a JSON/XML object downloaded by Digital Science Dimensions or PubMed APIs (through the packages dimensionsR and pubmedR.
es. file <- c(“file1.txt”, “file2.txt”, …)
convert2df creates a bibliographic data frame with cases corresponding to manuscripts and variables to Field Tag in the original export file.
convert2df accepts two additional arguments: dbsource and format.
The argument dbsource indicates from which database the collection has been downloaded.
It can be:
“isi” or “wos” (for Clarivate Analytics Web of Science database),
“scopus” (for SCOPUS database),
“dimensions” (for DS Dimensions database)
“pubmed” (for PubMed/Medline database),
“cochrane” (for Cochrane Library database of systematic reviews).
The argument format indicates the export file format. It can be one of the formats reported in Table 1.
Each manuscript contains several elements (metadata), such as authors’ names, title, keywords, and other information. All these elements constitute the bibliographic attributes of a document, also called metadata.
Data frame columns are named using the standard Clarivate Analytics WoS Field Tag codify.
The main field tags are:
|SO||Journal Name (or Source)|
|JI||ISO Source Abbreviation|
|ID||Keywords associated by SCOPUS or WoS database|
|RP||Corresponding Author’s Affiliation|
|UT||Unique Article Identifier|
For a complete list of field tags, see https://www.bibliometrix.org/documents/Field_Tags_bibliometrix.pdf
Clarivate Analytics Web of Science (WoS) (https://www.webofknowledge.com) is one of the world’s most trusted publisher-independent global citation databases. It was founded by Eugene Garfield, one of the pioneers of bibliometrics. This platform includes many different collections and allows users to export data in several different file formats.
bibliometrix supports three WoS export file formats: BibTeX, plaintext and EndNote Desktop.
To access Web of Science services, a subscription is required. When downloading data from Web of Science, make sure that the Web of Science Core Collection database is selected. Choose the Export option followed by EndNote Desktop file format, or Other File Formats option, and choose either the Plain Text or the BibTeX file format. Although bibliometrix supports all these file formats, we recommend the use of the plaintext format. When asked which data elements to download, choose the Full Record and Cited References option. Downloading cited reference data is necessary for identifying citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-citation links between items.
WoS BibTeX file format
WoS plaintext file format
WoS EndNote Desktop file format
Scopus (https://www.scopus.com/) is one of the largest abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed literature: scientific journals, books, and conference proceedings. Like WoS, Scopus allows to export data in several different file formats.
bibliometrix supports two Scopus export file formats: BibTeX and csv (comma-separated values).
TO access Scopus services, a subscription is required. To download data from Scopus, choose the CSV or the BibTeX export option. (Do not choose the Download option!) Make sure that the data is downloaded in a ‘.csv’ or ‘.bib’ file and that all data elements are included. Although bibliometrix supports both file formats, we recommend the use of the CSV format.
Scopus BibTeX file format
Scopus csv file format
Dimensions is s comprehensive database by Digital Science that doesn’t impose limitations on users. Like WoS, Scopus lets to export data in several different file formats. Dimensions is the only database that links publications and citations with grants, patents, clinical trials, datasets, and policy papers to deliver a more holistic view of the research landscape. Differently from WoS and Scopus, Dimensions allows exporting data in only two different file formats: excel and csv.
These two formats are not interchangeable but contain different types of metadata. In particular, Excel file contains metadata about document contents such as Abstract, Keywords, etc.. On the contrary, the csv file contains reference lists and affiliation names that can be used in citation and co-citation analyzes.
bibliometrix supports both the two Dimensions export file formats: excel and csv (comma-separated values).
The free version of Dimensions, for which no subscription is needed, can be used. A user account is required. To download data from Dimensions, choose the Save / Export option, followed by the Export for bibliometric mapping or Excel option.
Dimensions Excel file format
Dimensions csv file format
PubMed comprises more than 30 million citations for biomedical literature from MEDLINE, life science journals, and online books. Citations may include links to full-text content from PubMed Central and publisher web sites.
PubMed allows user to export data in many different file formats but the most suitable for science mapping analysis is the “pubmed txt” format. However, Any of these file formats contain metadata about citations and reference lists. This means that is not possible to perform citation and co-citation analysis using PubMed data.
bibliometrix supports only the “pubmed txt” file format.
PubMed can be accessed at https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/. To download data from PubMed, choose the Save option, choose All results as content selection, and choose PubMed as the file format. Data downloaded from PubMed cannot be used for identifying citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-citation links between items.
PubMed txt file format
The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (CDSR), owned by Cochrane Library, is a leading journal and database for systematic reviews in health care. CDSR includes Cochrane Reviews (systematic reviews) and protocols for Cochrane Reviews as well as editorials and supplements.
As for PubMed, CDSR allows to export many file formats but any of these contains metadata about citations and reference lists.
bibliometrix supports the “plaintext” file format.
CDSR can be accessed at https://www.cochranelibrary.com/search. To download data from CDSRed, choose the Export selected citation(s) option, and choose Plain Text as the file format. Data downloaded from CDSR cannot be used for identifying citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-citation links between items.
Cochrane plaintext file format
bibliometrix can download data through an API. The APIs supported by bibliometrix are listed in Table 2. The use of APIs requires an internet connection. bibliometrix will download data for all documents that match the specified search criteria defined by a query.
Dimensions API needs an account to obtain a valid token to query the database. The account can be obtain for free for scientometric reseaech project asking for it at https://www.dimensions.ai/scientometric-research/. Scopus API needs an API Key to work. Full Scopus APIs access is only granted to users with Scopus subscription (i.e. an academic subscription). These users can be request an API key at https://dev.elsevier.com/. FInally, by default, the access to PubMed API is free and does not necessarily require an API key. In this case, PubMed limits users to making only 3 requests per second. Users who register for an API key are able to make up to ten requests per second.
Obtaing a key is very simple, you just need to register for “my ncbi account” (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/account/) then click on a button in the “account settings page” (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/account/settings/).
At the moment, an important limitation of the Dimensions and PubMed APIs is that data downloaded through this API cannot be used for identifying citation, bibliographic coupling, and co-citation links between items.
The Dimensions API provides access to Dimensions data directly, and makes it possible to retrieve results to precise and complex queries. These are performed using the dimensionsR R-package functions which implement the Dimensions Search Language (DSL), a custom query language created by Dimensions.
The user can choose to write a valid query using that language or, in alternaative, using the function dsQueryBuild.
For a more detailed focus on the use of the dimensionsR package, please see the package vignette at https://cran.r-project.org/package=dimensionsR/vignettes/A_Brief_Example.html
The PubMed API provides access to PubMed data directly, submitting a query written following the pubmed query language. The PubMed data can be gathered using the pubmedR R-package functions.
For a more detailed focus on the use of the pubmedR package, please see the package vignette at https://cran.r-project.org/package=pubmedR/vignettes/A_Brief_Example.html